Short Communication - Journal of Pulmonology and Clinical Research (2017) Journal of Pulmonology and Clinical Research (Special Issue 1-2017)
Nurses knowledge regarding weaning criteria of the patients with mechanical ventilation in a teaching hospital, Chitwan.Pradhan C1, Shrestha R2*
- *Corresponding Author:
- Shrestha R
Chitwan Medical College
E-mail: [email protected]
Accepted Date: November 15, 2017
Citation: Pradhan C, Shrestha R. Nurses’ knowledge regarding weaning criteria of the patients with mechanical ventilation in a teaching hospital, Chitwan. J Pulmonol Clin Res. 2017;1(1):11-14.
Introduction: Ventilator weaning is the process of gradually withdrawing artificial ventilation to the intubated patients for short or long time in critical care setting. Weaning patients from ventilator is complex and challenging task for nurses and knowing weaning criteria is most essential component for getting successful outcome for the patients with mechanical ventilation. Hence, this study was conducted to find out nurses’ knowledge regarding weaning criteria of the patients with mechanical ventilation.
Methods: A descriptive cross sectional study design was used with 57 nurses working in critical care unit of a teaching hospital, Bharatpur, Chitwan. The non-probability, enumerative sampling technique was used. Data was collected by using self-administered semi structured questionnaire during July, 2016. Association was analyzed using chi square.
Results: The level of knowledge regarding weaning criteria was 45.6% had adequate knowledge while 54.4% had inadequate knowledge. The significant influencing variables for weaning criteria were professional experience (p ≤ 0.001), professional experience in critical care area (p ≤ 0.001), clinical areas (p=0.002) and age (p=0.006) among nurses.
Conclusion: More than half of the respondents had inadequate knowledge regarding weaning criteria and professional experience as a whole and critical care area, clinical area and age are influencing variables for weaning criteria among nurses working in a teaching hospital Chitwan. Hence, it is strongly recommended for need of protocol, in-service education, effective supervision and reinforcement for improvement of knowledge on weaning criteria among nurses.
Nurse, Knowledge, Weaning criteria, Mechanical ventilation.
Ventilator weaning refers to the restoration of independent breathing in an individual dependent on mechanically assisted ventilation, which involves gradually exposing the individual to longer periods of partially supported or independent breathing .
Ninety percentage of the ICU patient need mechanical ventilation support globally. Intubation and mechanical ventilation are often lifesaving procedures for them .
About 6,469,674 patients need hospitalization in the six states of USA reported that 180,326 (2.8%) received invasive mechanical ventilation. Projecting to national estimates, there were 790,257 hospitalizations involving mechanical ventilation approximately 20% of patients who received mechanical ventilation did not receive intensive care. .
Weaning patients from the ventilator is complex as the nurse needs to discontinue ventilation while providing continuous care, patient-focused, individualized weaning care plans and highlighting the expanding role of the ICU nurse .
Delays in weaning the patient from mechanical ventilation increase the number of complications and may lead to increased expenditure so the nurse must be well trained, should develop sound knowledge and practical skills in taking care of client with mechanical ventilator in order to develop them as effective potential and competent nurse practitioner .
About 90% of all ICU patients requiring mechanical ventilator support as a lifesaving measure. Approximately 30% of patients who require mechanical ventilation are not easily weaned .
Nurses must be knowledgeable about the function and limitations of ventilator modes, causes of respiratory distress and dysynchrony with the ventilator, and appropriate management in order to provide high-quality patient-centred care .
• To find-out nurses’ knowledge regarding weaning criteria of the patients with mechanical ventilation.
• To identify the nurses’ knowledge regarding weaning criteria of the patients with mechanical ventilation
• To find out the association between level of knowledge regarding weaning criteria of the patients with mechanical ventilation and selected variables.
Materials and Methods
A hospital based cross sectional study was conducted among fifty seven nurses’ working at the Chitwan Medical College Teaching Hospital, Chitwan. Non probability, enumerative sampling technique was used.
It was carried out at critical care units like Medicine Intensive Care Unit (MICU), Coronary Care Unit (CCU), and Surgery Intensive Care Unit (SICU)/Neuro Surgery Intensive Care Unit (NSICU). The study population was all the nurses working in critical care units of CMCTH who were Registered nurse, passed out PCL and Bachelor degree and who have >6 month experience in critical areas. Semi structured, self- administered questionnaire was used to measure the knowledge of respondents.
Socio-demographic characteristics of respondents
In regards to socio-demographic characteristics, out of 57 respondents, mean age was 22.79 ± 2.17 and majority of the respondents were belongs to 20-24 years (77.2%), unmarried (77.2%), residing in urban (68.4%), Hindu (98.2%), Brahmin/ Cherty (71.9%) professional qualification especially PCL nursing (61.4%),total professional experience ≤ 2years (78.9%), working in Medical intensive care unit and Surgical intensive care unit/Neurosurgery intensive care unit (38.6%) ,professional experience in critical care area ≤ 2years (89.5%), annual income less than or equal to 1, 50,000 (NPR) was (50.9%), did not get chance to have training on Mechanical Ventilation (75.4%), and guidelines on weaning criteria of mechanical ventilator available in their ward (50.9%) (Table 1).
Table: 1. Respondents’ socio-demographic characteristics n=57.
|Age group (in years)|
|Mean ± Standard Deviation=22.79 ± 2.177|
|Place of residence|
|Total professional experience (in years)|
|Medicine Intensive care Unit||22||38.6|
|Surgery Intensive care Unit/Neurosurgery Intensive care Unit||22||38.6|
|Coronary care Unit||13||22.8|
|Professional experience in critical care area|
|Annual Income (in NPR)|
|Training on mechanical ventilation|
|Available guidelines on weaning criteria|
Level of Knowledge regarding Weaning Criteria among Nurses had inadequate knowledge (54.4%) and adequate knowledge (45.6%) regarding weaning criteria (Table 2).
Table 2: Respondents’ level of knowledge regarding weaning criteria of mechanical ventilation (n=57).
|Level of knowledge||Number||Percentage|
Mean ± SD (19.61 ± 4.86).
Association between Level of Knowledge regarding Weaning Criteria and Selected Variables. Similarly, showed that association between level of knowledge regarding weaning criteria and selected variables. There is association between level of knowledge regarding weaning criteria with age (p ≤ 0.006), professional experience (p ≤ 0.001), clinical areas (p=0.002) and professional experience in critical area (p ≤ 0.001) (Table 3).
Table 3: Association between respondents’ level of knowledge regarding weaning criteria and selected variables.
|Variables||Level of Knowledge||χ2||p value|
|Inadequate No. (%)||Adequate No. (%)|
|Age (In Years)|
|20-24||29 (50.87)||15 (26.31)||7.477||0.006#|
|25-29||3 (5.26)||10 (17.54)|
|Married||5 (8.77)||8 (14.03)||2.138||0.144*|
|Unmarried||27 (47.3)||17 (29.82)|
|Place of Residence|
|Rural||13 (22.80)||5 (8.77)||2.763||0.096*|
|Urban||19 (33.33)||20 (35.08)|
|Hindu||31 (54.38)||25 (43.85)||0.795||0.373#|
|Non Hindu||1 (1.7)||-|
|Brahmin/Chhetri||21 (36.84)||20 (35.08)||1.436||0.231*|
|Janajati/Dalit||11 (19.29)||5 (8.77)|
|PCL Nursing||23 (71.9)||12 (48)||3.376||0.066*|
|Bachelor in nursing||9 (28.1)||13 (52)|
|Professional Experience (In years)|
|≤2||23 (40.35)||6 (10.52)||12.871||<0.001*|
|>2||9 (15.78)||19 (33.33)|
|ICU||20 (35.08)||24 (96)||12.269||0.002#|
|CCU||12 (21.05)||1 (1.75)|
|Professional experience in critical area (in years)|
|≤2||27 (47.36)||10 (17.54)||12.314||<0.001*|
|>2||5 (8.77)||15 (26.31)|
|Annual income (in NPR)|
|<1,50,000||15 (26.31)||14 (24.56)||0.468||0.494*|
|>1,50,000||17 (29.82)||11 (19.29)|
|Training on mechanical ventilation|
|Yes||7 (12.28)||7 (12.28)||0.284||0.594*|
|No||25 (43.85)||18 (31.57)|
|Available guideline on weaning criteria|
|Yes||15 (26.31)||14 (24.56)||0.468||0.494*|
|No||17 (29.82)||11 (19.29)|
Significant level at 0.05 #Fisher's exact *Pearson chi square.
The present study aimed to find-out knowledge regarding weaning criteria among nurses working in a teaching hospital, Chitwan. The major findings were reported:
(i) More than half of the nurses had inadequate knowledge regarding weaning criteria.
(ii) Age, total professional experience, critical care unit experience and clinical area were significant influencing variables for knowledge regarding weaning criteria among nurses.
This might be due to majority of nurses were of age group 20-24 years. This findings is contradictory with a another study finding conducted in Yenepoya Medical College Hospital, Deralakatte, Mangalore  revealed that age was not a influencing variable for level of knowledge on weaning criteria among nurse.
Regarding knowledge on ventilator weaning (54.4%) inadequate and (45.6%) adequate knowledge. The findings of this study was supported by a study conducted in Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University, Port Elizabeth, South Africa  reported that 92.5% of respondents obtained a knowledge score ≤ 50% whereas 7.5% of respondents obtained scores of ≥50% and analytical, cross sectional survey was also done at South Africa, Johannesburg which stated that knowledge of ICU trained nurses was found lacking.
Regarding knowledge on definition of mechanical ventilation (87.7%),definition on ventilator weaning (71.9%).The findings was supported by a hospital based descriptive study done in Koirala Institute of Health Science by stated that knowledge regarding definition of mechanical ventilation(100%),definition on ventilator weaning (82.9%) .
The findings of the study revealed that there is significant association between knowledge regarding weaning criteria and critical area (p ≤ 0.002). This finding was contradictory with a another study conducted in Yenepoya Medical College Hospital, Deralakatte, Mangalore by reported that critical area is not significant of level of knowledge on weaning criteria .
It is concluded that more than half of the nurses’ knowledge regarding weaning criteria of the patient with mechanical ventilation was inadequate. And age, total professional experience, critical care unit experience and clinical area were significant influencing variables for knowledge regarding weaning criteria among nurses.
- Newmarch C. Caring for the mechanically ventilated patient part one. Nursing Standard. 2016;20(17):55-64.
- McLean SE, Jensen LA, Schroeder DG, et al. Improving adherence to a mechanical ventilation weaning protocol for critically ill adult’s outcomes after an implementation program. American Journal of Critical Care. 2016;3:299-309.
- Wunsch H, Linde-Zwirble WT, Angus DC, et al. The epidemiology of mechanical ventilation use in the United States. Critical Care Medicine. 2010;38(10):1947-53.
- Lavelle C, Dowling M. the factors which influence nurses when weaning patients from mechanical ventilation findings from a qualitative study. Intensive and Critical Care Nursing. 2011;27(5):244-52.
- Joseph C, Vijayakumar C, Augustine J, et al. Nursing Care of patients on mechanical ventilation. Nursing Journal of India. 2006;95(10):231-2.
- Todorova L, Vassilev P, Matveev M, et al. Generalized net model of a protocol for weaning from mechanical ventilation. Proceeding of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. 2013;66(4):611-616.
- Grossbach I, Chlan L, Tracy MF. Overview of mechanical ventilatory support and management of patient-and ventilator-related responses. Critical Care Nurse. 2011; 31(3):30-44.
- Fathimath SKA, Jancy G, Jancy T, et al. Assessment of knowledge regarding mechanical ventilation among staff nurses working in selected hospital Mangalore with a view to develop an information pamphlet. International Journal of Recent Scientific Research. 2013;4(9):1410-1413.
- Demingo XP. Professional nurses’ knowledge regarding weaning the critically ill patient from mechanical ventilation (M.Sc. Nursing Thesis, South Africa: Nelson Mandela Metropolitan University) 2011.
- Perrie HC. Knowledge of intensive care nurses in selected care areas commonly guided by protocols. Doctoral dissertation, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg) 2006.
- Mehta RS, Bhattarai BK. Critical care nurses’ knowledge on adult mechanical ventilation management. 2012.