Biomedical Research

Review Paper - Biomedical Research (2019) Volume 30, Issue 1

The human papillomavirus, cervical cancer and screening strategies: an update.

Mahmood Rasool1, Sara Zahid2, Arif Malik2, Irshad Begum2, Hani Choudhry3, Shakeel Ahmed Ansari1, Siew Hua Gan4, Mohammad Amjad Kamal5, Muhammad Asif6, Fawzi Faisal Bokhari7, Nawal Helmi3,8, Mustafa Zeyadi3, Mohammed Hussein Al-Qahtani1 and Mohammad Sarwar Jamal5*

1Center of Excellence in Genomic Medicine Research (CEGMR), King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

2Institute of Molecular Biology and Biotechnology (IMBB), University of Lahore, Pakistan

3Department of Biochemistry, Cancer Metabolism and Epigenetic Unit, Faculty of Science, Cancer and Mutagenesis Unit, King Fahd Medical Research Center, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah 21589, Saudi Arabia

4Human Genome Centre, School of Medical Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, 16150 Kubang Kerian, Kelantan, Malaysia

5King Fahd Medical Research Center, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

6Department of Biotechnology, BUITEMS, Quetta, Pakistan

7Center for Health Studies, Armed Forces Hospitals, Taif Region, Taif, Saudi Arabia

8Department of Applied Biochemistry, Faculty of Sciences, University of Jeddah, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

*Corresponding Author:
Mohammad Sarwar Jamal
King Fahd Medical Research Center
King Abdulaziz University
Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

Accepted on August 29, 2018

Visit for more related articles at Biomedical Research

Abstract

Cervical cancer, the most common gynaecological malignancy has been strongly correlated with the infection of human papillomavirus (HPV). Different risk factors exaggerate the onset and progression of cervical cancer to malignant and metastatic state. Recent outcomes for the identification of the molecular pathways involved in cervical cancer provide clues about novel bio or oncogenic markers that are proved to be helpful in monitoring the detection of lesion with a high risk of progression in cytological smears and histological specimens. Sexual health programs and public awareness with developing strategies is the ultimate requirement for combating cervical cancer worldwide. The current review discusses mechanism of HPV that links with cervical cancer, various risk factors for the progression of cervical pathologies including smoking, oral contraceptives and sexual factors as well as diagnostic and screening strategies for cervical cancer.

Keywords

Papillomavirus, Cervical cancer, Metastasis, Diagnosis, Screening.

Introduction

Cervical cancer is accelerated ungoverned growth of anomalous cells of cervix; lower most portion of uterus that opens in vagina [1]. The cancer of cervical epithelium is one of the most widely occurring female malignancy having high death rates in developing countries and most commonly occurring cancer overall the world [2,3]. It has 5 y survival on average, 50% in developing countries and 66% in developed countries [4]. A non-communicable disease like cervical cancer creates devastating effects in the developing countries. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) and International Union (IUN) against cancer, 24.6 million people are living with cervical cancer around the world. In 2002 and 2008, cancer accounted for the deaths of 7.6 million people. Globally cervical cancer is the fifth and the second most frequent malignancy in men and women respectively. Overall, 715,000 new cervical cancer cases and 542,000 were estimated cervical cancer deaths in Africa. These risks take account of women who does smoke, have history of sexually transmitted diseases, human papillomavirus (HPV) infection, low socio economic position, multiple sexual partner, and suppressed immune system. These factors also support the criteria that cervical cancer is sexually transmitted disease [5]. Nicotine taken by smoking is not itself involved in progression of cervical cancer but it exaggerates it by suppressing immune status [6].

Cervical cancer and its precursor lesion is most important gynaecological revelation of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). Women with HIV are 3 times more risk at developing cervical cancer [7].

HPV infection is very commonly occurring due to its transmission nature, but very few of infections are progressed and meet malignancy and leads toward cervical cancer [8,9]. HPV is main cause for cervical carcinoma but it is proposed that some risks factors are associated with progression of cervical cancer.

The most important and widely contributing risk is high parity and oral contraceptives. If oral contraceptives are used in girls before 17 y at the same time having first sexual intercourse before age of 17 y may increase the risk of cervical cancer more [10]. These two risks are associated with high hormone levels and thus exaggerating the progression of cervical cancer [8].

The circulating levels of estrogen and progesterone are increased due to multi parity and by using long term oral contraceptives [11]. Increased estrogen levels cause the acidification of cervix which ultimately facilitate the squamous cell metaplasia [12].

HPV and Cervical Cancer

Human papilloma virus is so common in U.S. that almost every sexually active man and woman will transmit the virus during the lifetime. Approximately 10%-40% females are infected with HPV at any given time [13]. In spite of its most prevalent nature few people have knowledge of having this HPV infection because their symptoms are seldom noticeable [14].

Human papilloma virus is associated with number of diseases of which most serious is cervical cancer [15]. Almost 20% of human cancers have infectious agent as cause of occurrence. HPV infection is major etiological cause for the development of cervical cancer [16]. HPV causing cervical cancer has oncogenic HPV types and most commonly occurring HPV-16.

Combined studies have concluded that 99.7% of all cervical cancers contain HPV and it is highest fraction worldwide for any cause of human cancers [17]. The link between HPV and cervical cancer was first demonstrated in 1980’s and identified that 29 types of HPV are involved in causing cancer and confirmed that HPV is present necessarily in all types of cervical cancers [18,19].

Over 150 types of HPV have been known to infect genital tract [20]. Out of these 15 are thought to be known high risk HPV [21]. High risk HPV types are: 16, 18, 31, 33, 35, 39, 45, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, 68, 73 and 82. HPV 31, 33, 35, 52 and 58 are phylogenetically identical to HPV 16. HPV 39, 45, 59 and 68 are thought to be similar with HPV 18.

Most of the cervical cancer cases are associated with HPV 16 and 18 15.2% and 16.2% respectively. Other than HPV 16 and 18 other types are also associated with cervical cancer for example 39, 45, 59 and 68. HPV 16 is most frequently found in squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) and HPV 18 is most prevalent in adenocarcinoma (ADC) [22].

Mechanism of Human Papillomavirus-Potential Therapeutic Targets

Many strains of human papillomavirus have been reported so far which are classified on the basis of their oncogenicity: high risk HPV forms have been involved in the progression of cervical cancers while low risk varieties may rarely be involved in cancerous lesions [23]. There are at present fifteen HPV viruses of high risk category. The two most common HPV varieties are HPV-16 and HPV-18 [18]. The E6 and E7 proteins of high risk strains of HPV are the regulatory proteins involved in oncogenesis. E6 is mainly associated with the lifting of restrictions on cellular proliferation and E7 is involved in cell cycle progression. E2 is also associated with the regulation of cell cycle progression through the expression of E6/E7 which results in the up-regulation of cellular proliferation and enhanced tumerogenesis [18,24]. HPV E2 also possesses an anti-tumor effect when it is introduced into HPV transformed experimental model [25]. High risk E6 and E7 inhibit the innate immune response in immune-competent mice showing its immune-modulatory effect [26]. E6 inhibits the trans-activation function of Interferon regulatory factor-3 (IRF-3) by binding to it whereas E7 represses the transcriptional activity of IRF-1 by binding the IFN-β promoter. Since IFN signalling is significantly involved in innate immune response which subsequently activates adaptive immunity, E6 and E7 proteins delay this activation and contribute to the progression of prolonged persistent HPV infection leading to the increased risk of malignant infection [27].

An important and most convincing fact is that E6 protein helps in the association of DNA binding protein expressed in response to DNA damage to the tumor suppressor protein p53 which causes unscheduled induction of DNA replication resulting in cell cycle arrest or apoptosis [28]. HPV has such a structure that it depends on the cellular DNA synthesis machinery. So it is interpreted that HPV stimulates the progression of S-phase for the replication of its genome. Overexpression of p53 represents a major impairment for viral replication [29]. Binding of E6 with p53 is stimulated bys cellular ubiquitin ligase and E6 associated protein (E6-AP) which recruits the ubiquitin complex of enzymes, ubiquitin atinglysines on p53 causing its proteolysis. Degradation of p53 arrests the normal growth signals at G1/S and G2/M checkpoints in cell cycle which is responsible for the chromosomal instability causing mutational consequences for HPV positive cells [30]. E6 oncoprotein also plays a major role in blocking the degradation of SRC-kinases by E6-AP causing mitotic activity [31].

Risk Factors

Different risk factors are associated with cervical cancer. These risks are menarche, high parity, an early age at first sexual intercourse, multiple male sex partners, and a history of sexually transmitted diseases, smoking, certain nutritional deficiencies, and low socioeconomic status. There are several independent risk factors for causing cervical cancers including age at menarche, age at first delivery, menopause status, and long term estrogen exposure status. The short gap between menarche and start of sexual activity increases the risk for development of cervical cancer [4].

Women having multiple sexual partners significantly increase the risk of developing cervical cancer. And most probably, women reporting approximately 10 partners are at three folds risk of developing cervical cancer. Multiple births and under age at first delivery also exaggerate the risk of developing cervical cancer [32] (Table 1).

 Risk classification HPV types
High-risk 16, 18, 31, 33, 35, 39, 45, 51, 52, 56, 58, 59, 68, 73 and 82
Low-risk 6, 11, 40, 42, 43, 44, 54, 61, 70, 72, 81 and CP6108

Table 1. Classification of HPV types based on risk for carcinogenesis [21].

Sexual and Reproductive Risk Factors

Sexual behaviour concludes the exposure to HPV such as multiple sexual partners, unprotected sex, and woman’s partner having multiple partner, and early age at sexual intercourse. Out of these risk factors early age at first sexual intercourse (AFSI) is of major importance. Increased risk of HPV is linked with the fact that cervix is immature in adolescents so early sexual intercourse can make it more vulnerable toward the infection of HPV and finally the development of cervical cancer [33]. Early pregnancy is also involved in development of cervical cancer as being major risk factor in the way that women who are married at an early age or get involved in early sexual intercourse may become pregnant, cervical damaged may occur during early age at delivery and ultimately make cervical cells vulnerable to develop cervical cancer [33]. This true with high parity birth or multiple births as trauma to cervix can occur during multiple deliveries. How the early age at first pregnancy and early at sexual intercourse exaggerates the risk of developing cervical cancer may be understood steroid hormonal impact on HPV infection and on immune response of host to HPV during preadolescence and adolescence [33]. Site of cervical cancer development is transformation zone; the susceptibility of this area is linked with its nature. Denudation of stratified epithelium of cervix in between puberty and pregnancy the exposure of cervix to hormonal changes is increased. Increased estrogen levels cause the acidification of cervix which ultimately facilitate the squamous cell metaplasia when the endocervical epithelial avert. This estrogen stimulated meta-plastic changes occurring in the presence of HPV thereby increases risk of cellular transformation that induces neoplasia [12]. It is also believed that these metaplastic changes are increased during trauma and repair process after pregnancies [12]. Increased estrogen can also affect host immune response against HPV. Estrogen levels are three fold higher during follicular phase of the ovarian cycle and pregnancy, these increased levels increases estrogen receptors and their expression in transformation zone [12].

Smoking

Smoking is one of the most important risk factor in the development of cervical cancer. The risk of malignancy is increased with amount and total time period of smoking [10]. The current literature suggests that there is a significant relationship between cervical cancer and smoking, because the women who smoke frequently are at the two fold increased risk of getting cervical cancer [4,10]. Cigarette carcinogens are accumulated in cervical mucus and serve as possible biological factors for the progression cervical cancer. These carcinogens have ultimate transforming effect on the cervical epithelium [4]. Smoking also increases the event of death due to cervical cancer [4]. Researchers believe that these substances damage the DNA of cervix cells and may contribute to the development of cervical cancer. Smoking also makes the immune system less effective in fighting HPV infections. Smoking acts by multiple ways to induce and increase the risk for having cervical cancer (Figure 1). Nicotine rich smoke of cigarettes inhibits apoptosis and subsequently promotes tumor growth [34]. Tobacco increases DNA modification of cervical epithelium through post translational modification and makes favourable circumstances to induce cervical cancer [35]. And secondly nitroso compounds in tobacco induce cervical cancer progression (Figure 2) [35].

biomedres-Molecular-mechanism

Figure 1: Molecular mechanism of human papilloma virus (HPV) oncogenesis.

biomedres-smoking-cervix

Figure 2: (A) OPHN1 wild type protein model (Ala688) structure in PyMOL; (B) OPHN1 mutant type protein model (Ser688) structure in PyMOL; (C) Superimposition of wild and mutant type protein models using YASARA.

Oral Contraceptives and Molecularity

It is suggested from studies that use of oral contraceptives induces risk of cervical cancer in HPV positive women [10,35,36]. Long duration of oral contraceptive use increases the risk of cervical cancer. After the cut down of oral contraceptives the risk associated with is decreased but this hypothesis is proved by limited researches [36,37]. The risk associated with oral contraceptives is similar for all types of cervical cancers [38]. The women using combination of estrogen and progesterone currently were at 4 fold increased susceptible towards the risk associated with cervical cancer [39]. There is consistent and high risk associated with long term contraceptive use for developing cervical cancer. It is suggested from past experimental work that progesterone and estrogen present in contraceptives that these two hormones render the host immune response related to HPV evasion [36].

Contraceptives used at age less than 17 y increases more significantly the risk of having cervical cancer. If oral contraceptives are used in girls before 17 y at the same time having first sexual intercourse before age of 17 y may increase the risk of cervical cancer more [10]. The possible mechanism by which oral contraceptives become potent risk factor indicated that oral contraceptive may increases cervical ectopy which leads to the progression of cervical malignancy [10,37]. Other ways suggested that hormonal recognition elements are present on the transcriptional region of HPV 16 DNA.

Oral contraceptives increase this biding with HPV 16 DNA and thus enhance HPV induced transformation of cervical cells [10]. Oral contraceptives induce local folic acid deficiencies and disturb DNA synthesis, repair and make cell more susceptible towards carcinogens and enhance risk for cervical abnormalities. So long term use of oral contraceptives is the major risk factor for cervical cancer [37].

Education Level and Socioeconomic Status

Low socioeconomic status (SES) is greatly linked with risk of cervical cancer. The reason behind this link is not fully understood but it is perceived that women having low SES have inadequate screening and showing high parity [40]. Education level serves as a marker for combined risk factor which may occur in women with low SES and become significant risk for cervical cancer. Early events in women’s life living low socioeconomic status can modify the potential of HPV inducing cervical cancer. These events may be like early age at sexual intercourse and multiple pregnancies [40].

Hormones as Enhancer

Another remarkable cofactor linked to the induction of cervical cancer by HPV is estrogen. Oral contraceptives containing estrogen provide good environment for the long term infection of HPV leading to carcinoma of cervical epithelium [39]. Excess and long term use of oral contraceptives is associated with doubling the chance of neoplasia and malignancy induced by HPV [39].

During pregnancy there is increased levels of estrogen which enhance the HPV induced cervical cancer. Some studies also suggested that tumors in cervix expressing both E7 and E6 alone or in concert are estrogen dependent for the onset of progression after initial beginning of infection. Estrogen may acts as carcinogen or as mitogen [41].

Screening and Cytology of HPV

The majority of the women with cervical cancer experience long asymptomatic period until and unless it is clinically manifested (5). Therefore, regular and proper cytological screening i.e. detecting and removing abnormal tissue or cells in the cervix to treat cervical neoplasia is needed to prevent progression of precancerous lesion to malignant and active cancer. It is proposed that screening work is very low in developing countries because it is not yet confirmed that whether these screening strategies are cost effective in developing countries where cervical cancer is most common cancer next to breast cancer [42]. It is common cancer of low income countries because poor women are less likely to be screened who are more likely to come under exposure of common risks of cervical cancer i.e. smoking and unsafe sex [42,43]. Screening is an important step for preventing cervical cancer [44]. The disease burden and worldwide health inequalities would be decreased by improving effective coverage of screening for lowering cervical cancer prevalence [42]. Pap cytology has contributed much in decreasing cervical cancer prevalence; incidence and death rate worldwide [44].

Pap smear testing should begin at age of 18 or after starting sexual life. After having 3 consecutive negative Pap smear results Pap test should be repeated after every 3 y. This way should be adopted in countries having controlled and proper screening system and compiled information regarding that [44]. If this sort of system is missing, pap screening should be repeated after every one year. If mild dysplasia or cervical intraepithelial neoplasia 1 (CIN1) (Table 2) is seen Pap test should be repeated after 6 months. If moderate dysplasia or CIN 2 occurs patient should be advised to perform colposcopy [45]. Despite of successful reduction of cervical incidence by Pap smear some biomarkers are now available for improving cervical cancer screening procedures. These biomarker tools are really important for diagnosis and screening of CIN and cervical cancer [46].

CIN 1 Mild dysplasia
CIN 2 Moderate dysplasia
CIN 3 Severe dysplasia and carcinoma

Table 2. Three grades for recognizing the cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN).

Cervical cancer screening is thought to decrease the risk for spreading of HPV among sexually active persons to about 90%. In the absence of screening there is more chance to develop cancer after the age of 20-25 y. So it is recommended to have Pap screening after every 3 y at least after the age of puberty. Some studies suggested that screening interval should be reduced to 3 y in women having age 25-49 y. For women aged 50 to 64 the interval should be 5 y [47]. Understanding the role of HPV in epidemiology of cervical cancer HPV has gained much importance for the screening of cervical cancer. HPV testing has changed the thinking of women in understanding cervical cancer [48-52]. Pap smear cytology contributed much for controlling cervical cancer. In spite of its successful results Pap is not much perfect. Pap smear test is time consuming and leads to fatigue which causes errors in cytological results. Sampling errors while taking sample from cervix can occur, following laboratory aberrations and thus making it less reliable. Sometimes Pap test shows false positive results which increases patient’s anxiety and expenses [44]. All these pitfalls compelled medical technological industry to design new tests with high sensitivity for the detection of precursors of cervical cancer having perfection. HPV testing via viral DNA detection is designed to complete such laps. It detect high risk HPV virus causing cervical cancer [44]. By adding HPV testing to normal cervical cancer screening program the efficacy was increased. HPV testing can be helpful in both ways; as a combining tool with normal Pap smear cytology to raise the efficacy of current Pap cytology program or as a self-contained test for cervical screening. HPV testing doesn’t demand much training as with Pap smear test. So it is very good tool to be used as screening in third world countries where overall mortality is high due to cervical cancer [44,53,54].

Conclusion

Studies have shown that HPV infection is associated with the cervical cancer. Multiple risk factors are responsible for the onset and progression of cervical cancer to malignant and metastatic state. Advancements in molecular targets of this disorder will help for the management of this disorder. Proper and accurate screening will also help for the management of cervical cancer. The most important thing is to give awareness to people for this disease before they get occupied by incurable health issue.

Conflict of Interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of financial interests.

References