Research Article - Biomedical Research (2017) Volume 28, Issue 20
The effectiveness of active warming for women undergoing elective caesarean section on maternal shivering: A meta-analysis
Shao Gang, Shi Zhengyuan and Jiang Chunnan*
People’s Hospital of Danyang, Jiangsu Province, China
Accepted on October 13, 2017
Objective: To explore the effectiveness of active warming for women undergoing elective caesarean section on maternal shivering.
Methods: We searched Medline and Embase databases to identify publications evaluating the efficacy of active warming for women undergoing elective caesarean section on maternal shivering. 11 studies that fulfilled the specified criteria entered into analysis.
Results: The result of our analysis showed active warming could reduce the incidence of shivering in patients undergoing caesarean section with spinal anesthesia compared with no active warming control group (OR 0.55, CI (0.39, 0.77)).
Conclusions: Our analysis suggests that active warming could reduce shivering in patient undergoing caesarean section with spinal anesthesia compared with no warming.
Active warming, Caesarean section, Shivering, Meta-analysis.
Shivering is a frequent event after cesarean section under spinal anesthesia. Shivering is known to have many potentially detrimental effects including increased oxygen consumption, carbon dioxide production and cardiac work, as well as causing maternal discomfort . The exact etiology of shivering is unknown, the best way to prevent and treat shivering after spinal anesthesia is unclear. Currently there are no routine warming during caesarean delivery to prevent shivering, Despite several studies investigating active warming during caesarean delivery, there is still no consensus regarding whether it decreases shivering, The objective of this meta-analysis was to evaluate the effectiveness of active warming on maternal shivering after caesarean delivery under spinal anesthesia.
Search strategy and selection criteria
This analysis was performed according to the PRISMA guideline , Medline and Embase database were carefully searched to identify relevant publications indexed between January 1980 and October 2016, using following key words including “caesarean/cesarea” or “obstetric” and “warming” or ‘temperature”, abstracts were reviewed and the articles which focus on warming during caesarean section were obtained in full version. We conducted a review for the references of identified studies and limited the language in English.
Attempts were made to contact the corresponding authors if further unpublished data were needed.
Any randomized controlled study that met the inclusion criteria with reduction of shivering as an outcome was considered. The review included adults undergoing elective cesarean section under spinal anesthesia, receiving active warming including forced air warming devices, warmed intravenous fluids, warmed mattresses and warmed coverings to prevent shiver.
Three reviewers independently extracted data from each study. Results were compared and any disagreements were resolved by consensus. The extracted data included: first author, year, method of warming (including forced air warming devices, warmed intravenous fluids, warmed mattresses and warmed coverings), anesthetic technique, incidence of shivering in active warming group and control group.
Data were collected and analysed using STATA software (version 12.0 STATA Corp., College Station, TX). We considered an I2 statistic of 50% or more as indicative of a considerable level of heterogeneity, if I2>50%, the random effects model was used . Otherwise, the fixed effect model was used. For dichotomous outcomes, the Odds Ratio (OR) and 95% Confidence Interval (CI) were calculated (OR<1 favored warming).
Our initial literature search identified 738 studies, finally, 11 studies were included in our analysis [4-14], and a total of 647 patients were enrolled in these studies: 343 patients in the active warming group and 304 in the control group. Basic characteristics of the 11 studies are shown in Table 1.
|Author||Method of warming||Active warming group||Shivering||Control group||Shivering|
|Kishore ||Fluid||35||16 (45.71%)||35||18 (51.42%)|
|Chakladar ||Resistive warming mattress||58||10 (17.2%)||58||8 (13.8%)|
|Jorgensen ||Warm saline||57||8 (14%)||56||14 (25%)|
|Bernardis ||Thermal gown||20||2 (10%)||20||8 (40%)|
|Cobb ||IV fluid and forced-air warming||22||10 (45.5%)||22||17 (77.3)|
|Horn ||A forced-air cover||19||0||21||5 (24%)|
|Chung ||Forced-air warming and intravenous warmed fluids||30||5 (16.7%)||15||8 (53.3%)|
|Woolnough ||Fluid||50||16 (32%)||25||11 (44%)|
|Butwick ||Forced air-warming unit||15||4 (27%)||15||7 (47%)|
|Horn ||Forced air heating||15||2 (13.3%)||15||9 (60%)|
|Workhoven ||Warm fluid||22||3 (14%)||22||14 (64%)|
Table 1. Characteristics of the 11 studies.
Findings from the meta-analysis investigating the effectiveness of active warming on the incidence of shivering are shown in Figure 1. When data were pooled across studies, we found a reduction in the incidence of active warming group (OR 0.55, CI (0.39, 0.77)). Heterogeneity wasn’t observed (P=0.434; I2=0.8%). We used the fixed effects model for the analysis.
This meta-analysis included 11 RCTs within the specific population of women undergoing cesarean section. We limited subjects undergoing elective cesarean section with spinal anesthesia who were given active warming including forced air warming devices, warmed intravenous fluids, warmed mattresses and warmed coverings, our meta-analysis was aimed to explore the efficacy of active warming for women undergoing elective caesarean section on maternal shiver. The result of our analysis showed active warming could reduce the incidence of shivering in patients undergoing caesarean section with spinal anesthesia compared with no active warming control group.
The mechanism of shivering during regional anesthesia is not understood. For many years it has been the clinical practice to warm air, fluid, mattress or covering, the rationale for active warming is to preserve core temperature and to reduce shivering and discomfort. The effectiveness of active warming strategies in this population was confirmed by this review. Active warming provided clinical value in reducing shivering even if it was used for relatively short periods. In this article, different active warming methods involved, we couldn’t conclude that which warming method was better than another warming method, as they were not directly compared with each other. Future studies could explore the optimal warming method and to assess whether the combination of methods had an advantage over a single one. Our meta-analysis suggested that either warming methods could reduce shivering compared with no warming.
In summary, based on the results from this meta-analysis we recommended that active warming should be used for caesarean delivery in order to reduce the incidence of maternal shivering, further studies are needed to evaluate which warming method is more effective, whether the combination of warming methods is more effective than a single one, and how long pre-anesthetic warming must be set up to prevent shivering.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors had no conflicts of interest to declare in relation to this article.
- Matsukawa T, Sessler DI, Christensen R. Heat flow and distribution during epidural anesthesia. Anesthesiology 1995; 83: 961-967.
- Moher D, Liberati A, Tetzlaff J. Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Int J Surg 2010; 8: 336-341.
- Higgins JP, Thompson SG. Quantifying heterogeneity in a meta-analysis. Stat Med 2002; 21: 1539-1558.
- Kishore N, Payal YS, Kumar N. Spinal anaesthesia for cesarean section the temperature of bupivacaine affects the onset of shivering but not the incidence: a randomized control trial. J Clin Diag Res 2016; 10: 18-21.
- Chakladar A, Dixon MJ, Crook D. The effects of a resistive warming mattress during caesarean section: a randomised, controlled trial. Int J Obstetr Anesth 2014; 23: 309-316.
- Jorgensen HS, Bach LF, Helbo-Hansen HS. Warm or cold saline for volume preload before spinal anaesthesia for caesarean section? Int J Obstetr Anesth 2000; 9: 20-25.
- Bernardis RCGD, Siaulys MM, Vieira JE. Perioperative warming with a thermal gown prevents maternal temperature loss during elective cesarean section. A randomized clinical trial. Braz J Anesthesiol 2015; 66: 451-455.
- Cobb B, Cho Y, Hilton G. Active warming utilizing combined i.v. fluid and forced-air warming decreases hypothermia and improves maternal comfort during cesarean delivery: a randomized control trial. Anesth Analg 2016; 122: 1490-1497.
- Horn EP, Bein B, Steinfath M. The incidence and prevention of hypothermia in new-born bonding after cesarean delivery: a randomized controlled trial. Anesth Analg 2014; 118: 997-1002.
- Chung SH, Lee BS, Yang HJ. Effect of preoperative warming during cesarean section under spinal anesthesia. Korean J Anesthesiol 2012; 62: 454-460.
- Woolnough M, Allam J, Hemingway C. Intra-operative fluid warming in elective caesarean section: a blinded randomised controlled trial. Int J Obstetr Anesth 2009; 18: 346-351.
- Butwick AJ, Lipman SS, Carvalho B. Intraoperative forced air-warming during cesarean delivery under spinal anesthesia does not prevent maternal hypothermia. Anesth Analg 2007; 105: 1413-1419.
- Horn EP, Schroeder F, Gottschalk A. Active warming during cesarean delivery. Anesth Analg 2002; 94: 409-414.
- Workhoven MN. Intravenous fluid temperature, shivering, and the parturient. Anesth Analg 1986; 65: 496-498.