Review Article - Journal of Fisheries Research (2018) Volume 2, Issue 2
Apprehensions and issues related to pacu Piaractus brachypomus (Cuvier 1818) farming in IndiaAtul K Singh*
Emeritus Scientist at ICAR- National Bureau of Fish Genetic Resources, Lucknow-226002 (Uttar Pradesh), India.
- Corresponding Author:
- Atul K Singh
Emeritus Scientist at ICAR- National Bureau of Fish Genetic Resources
Lucknow-226002 Former Director ICAR-DCFR Uttar Pradesh India
Email: [email protected]
Accepted date: June 7, 2018
Citation: Singh AK. Apprehensions and issues related to pacu Piaractus brachypomus (Cuvier 1818) farming in India J Fish Res 2018;2(2):19-23.
In India, recently introduced pacu fish farming is picking up fast without envisaging scientific track to promote or regulate it. The unofficially introduced pacu in India is projected to be Piaractus brachypomus relying on the identifying characteristics. However, the species available in aquaculture and that in aquarium trade is yet to be scientifically validated. The identification of juvenile fish available at hatcheries, farms and aquarium shops based on morphological features may not be correct particularly when possibility of existing different species of pacu and their interspecific hybrids may exist. Monitoring, risk assessment and identification of the individual species should be scientifically conducted. In India, the farm-raised pacu grows well but its production differs from farm to farm. The fish can utilize diets high in carbohydrates and plant proteins, tolerates poor water quality conditions, varied environments and culture conditions. Breeding of the fish is now well established for its farm raising and propagation yet ornamental value of the fish has also further fascinated aquarium shopkeepers and hobbyists to keep and propagate it in different states of the country. Farm raising, hatchery production and aquarium trading of pacu facilitated inadvertant releases of introduced pacu which has gravitated into several natural water bodies. It is proposed that the available pacu farms and hatcheries need to be urgently registered in view of proper management and scientific regulations on pacu farming. Based on the synthesized and field oriented information presented in this study, there are several apprehensions of adverse ecological concerns and consequences. The issues and concerns of rapid expansion of pacu in the country draws attention of the policy makers and the scientific community to address them keeping in view of the larger interest of the farmers community, society and the environment.
Pacu, Aquaculture, Spread, Environment, Invasion.
The so-called fish pacu Piaractus brachypomus (Cuvier 1818) was unofficially introduced possibly during 2004 via Bangladesh [1,2]. As per information available in Fishbase, there are 12 species of pacus . The popular species of pacu are Colossoma macropomum (tambaqui), Piaractus brachypomus and Piaractus mesopotamicus. Red-bellied pacu and black pacu have been reported from India . Nevertheless, Piaractus brachypomus (Cuvier 1818) commonly known as pacu, pirapitinga, roopchanda is understood to be available at many of the farms, markets and aquarium shops of Indian states and the fish has got both food and ornamental value. In addition, another pacu like species called piranha is also available which belongs to the family Characidae and subfamily Serrasalmidae belonging to the same group . The morphological information, characteristics and biology of pacus found in India are yet to be scientifically validated. At the juvenile stage, pacu resembles piranha (Pygocentrus natteri), but differs greatly in behaviour and feeding habits even though they belong to the same family . Since the boundaries of the country are porous, pacu piracy and unauthorized introductions have been carried out  and actually needed scientific information are lacking. The unofficial culture and breeding of pacu in India has been expanding during recent past causing concern of local fish biodiversity management and encouraging aquaculture for food security. As per reports available, a significant subset of alien species can become invasive and have serious adverse impact on biodiversity and related ecosystem services, as well as have other social and economic impact .
Internationally, culture and breeding technology of pacus Colossoma macropomum (tambaqui), Piaractus brachypomus and Piaractus mesopotamicus is now well established and available . However, it is also important to mention that in recent years, hybrids of pacus have also been produced and reported to represent recent advances in aquaculture of pacu . Since three species of pacus Colossoma macropomum (tambaqui), Piaractus brachypomus and Piaractus mesopotamicus are very common at farms and hatcheries in several countries, morphological distinction of such unintentional or deliberate hybrids production from the parents becomes highly unidentifiable, particularly between interspecific hybrids and pure species individuals. It is thus difficult to generate species specific information of the individuals available at the farms and markets. Hybrids pacu can be erroneously identified as pure species in breeding facilities, which might reduce production on farms and negatively affect native populations due to escapes or stocking practices . These deliberate or unintentional activities of hybrid production if any is considered to be more resistant to varied environmental factors . Further, mislabeling of the existing species may become a cheat to the market and farmers as the hybrids may not be as productive and remunerative for cultivation and aquaculture as that of pure species . Nevertheless, genetic and environmental problems are also foreseen and since different species of pacus are reproductively compatible .
The propagule pressure on the pacu fish farming in India is equal for aquaculture as food and also for ornamental keeping [9,10]. It is quite likely that attempts are in operation or may be made towards creating fancy appearance of the fish through crossbreeding of different species of pacu for value addition especially in ornamental trade. It is therefore, imperative to ensure what species farmers are cultivating and demonstrate authenticity. Absence of monitoring by competent agencies/ authorities/scientific organizations, the warnings reported by Hashimoto et al. (2012)  based on experience elsewhere particularly in the USA and Asia will be needed towards the implementation of regulatory measures and management endeavours. Keeping in view of the above facts, present scenario on the culture and breeding of pacu in India has been synthesized and presented in this paper. Further, various environmental conditions required for the fish to spread has also been generated so as to make out possible invasions. The instances of inadvertant releases of the fish in different natural aquatic bodies are highlighted besides lessons to be learnt from the other countries to contemplate scientific measures to regulate culture and propagation of pacu in India.
Aquaculture of pacu
Both red-bellied pacu Piaractus brachypomus and the black pacu Colossoma macropomum have been found to grow well both in the natural environment  as well as in captivity. They exhibit excellent characteristics for use in aquaculture [12,13]. They can:
• reproduce under captive conditions
• thrive low on the food chain
• acccept prepared feed
• tolerate hardy conditions
• can easily be handled,
• grow rapidly
• be cultivated in high density
• be marketed and have consumers acceptability
• fetch good price and
• be preferred as food as well as ornamental fish.
They exhibit fast growth, and are able to utilize diets having high in carbohydrates and plant proteins. They are resistance to poor water quality conditions and diseases having good flesh quality. They have high ornamental value and attractive aquaculture characteristics. Red-bellied pacu, Piaractus brachypomus, is though native of Brazil is now introduced to Iran, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru, Venezuela, India Bangladesh, Nepal, Malaysia and Philippines and many more countries. It is cultivated in India, under extensive or semi-intensive type of culture both as monoculture and polyculture .
Pacu in India is mostly cultivated in Inland coastal areas of West Godavari and Krishna Districts with low productive soils. In most of the areas, pacu is cultured in combination with mainly rohu (Labeo rohita) or even with catla (Catla catla) and mrigal (Cirrhinus mrigala) at a stocking density of 7000 and 5000 per hectare respectively with total production levels of 12-15 MT/ha [14,15]. Although Piaractus branchypomus is one of the introduced species being cultured in the state of Andhra Pradesh alone in an area of over 1000 hectares, its compatability with Indian major caprs in mixed/poly culture has not been fully understood. Its culture has now spread in other states such as Maharashtra, Tamil nadu, Karnataka, Kerala, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Orrissa and north eastern states [1,2]. Nevertheless, there is no standard practice of its culture; the farmers are doing it at their own discretions and convenience. The production of the fish varies from farm to farm and overall production in the country is assessed to cross 0.2 million tonnes /ha/year.
The culture and breeding of the fish was begun in the state of West Bengal and gained popularity in Andhra Pradesh [1, 2, 9,16]. Pacu has been found to attain maturity at 3 years or more with a stocking density of 2,000-2,500 fish/ha at different hatcheries. Today there are over 65 pacu hatcheries existing in different districts of the West Bengal (Table 1). The technology required for the reproduction of pacu through hormonal induction has been well established and widely used . However, the major breeding activities are undertaken in West Bengal while farmers at other places such as Orrissa, Andhra Pradesh, Kerala, northeaster states, Uttar Pradesh etc have also successfully attempted breeding producing pacu seed in a limited numbers. As per report of NBFGR, seed production from West Bengal during the last five years indicated about three fold increase in spawn, fry and fingerlings production in the surveyed hatcheries which were approximately 553 millions, 196 million and 8,4 million respectively . In view of perpetuating farms and hatcheries in the country, there is urgent need to register them in view of proper control and scientific regulations.
|Sl No||Name of District||Names of Blocks||No. of Hatcheries|
|7.||MURSHIDABAD||BERHAMPORE, NABAGRAM, SAGARDIGHI||3|
|9.||NORTH 24 PARGANAS||AMDANGA, BADURIA, BARRACKPORE-I, BONGAON, GAIGHATA, HABRA-II, SWARUPNAGAR, BASANTI-I, BHANGAR-II, BUDGE BUDGE-I, MOGRAHAT-II||51|
Table 1: Information on Pacu hatcheries available in the West Bengal
Pacu fish species has been reported to be cultivated in a wide range of latitudes and temperatures [18,19]. The natural distribution of the fish occurs on a wide range of temperatures ranging from 12°C-15°C up to 27°C . Young ones have been found to survive at temperatures between 20°C and 30°C and at pH 6-8  while the optimal temperature for growth is 23°C-28°C . The fish is also reported to survive in depths of up to 20 m  and they are a thermophilic species capable of tolerating low and high chronic temperatures of 16.5°C and 35°C, respectively.
Piaractus brachypomus is highly capable of thriving in various aquatic environments and it is a hardy species, which can rapidly shift its dietary habits. It can survive in degraded environment and at depleted oxygen levels . Adult pacu is highly adaptable to environmental hypoxia however, oxygen concentrations below 4 mg/L severely impacted survival of embryos . The abrupt transfer of the fish from freshwater to slightly saline water and the return to freshwater did not affect the survival rates and the survival was found to range between 89 to 97%. The larvae can also quickly adapt saline environments and abrupt changes in salt concentration .
Invasion risks of Pacu in natural water bodies
Introduction of fish species is a globally widespread practice that is now serious consideration as such practices cause losses to native species and homogenization of diversity within and across continents . In Florida, pacu was first observed in the wild during the 1960's and initially the pacu population was thought to be non-breeding and existed only as the escapees of residential aquariums and hence non-invasive. However, they later on colonised and today they are everywhere, from South Florida canals, to Lake Okeechobee and through-out most of the continental United States .
Invasions of red-bellied Pacu populations have further been reported from many other countries such as Philippines, Iran, and Hungary etc. Pacu being South American native fish has been reported to occur near Yuma, Arizona in June 2006 and in New Jersy in June 2015 . The occurrence of pacu has also been reported in Denmark, Michigan and other places. However, invasiveness of the species has yet to be determined. So far as the ecological issues are concerned, there is a report from Papua New Guinea in 2011, where incidence of two human deaths was reported due to Pacu attack by biting off the testicles of fishermen . The species possesses a powerful dentition that can also cause serious bites to humans and other aquatic organisms and damage to fishing nets such as gill and cast nets as reported in the reservoir of Pune, India . Some of the reports available from different countries where pacu were introduced and escaped into natural aquatic bodies are presented here so as to understand possible risks of its culture and propagation keeping in view of the international scenario:
The Brazilian red-bellied pacu, has been found to adapt very well in ornamental aquarium fishes in the Philippines and also food fish after its introduction during 1980s. The fish can now reproduce in captive conditions and be cultured in ponds for use as an ornamental fish . It is an expensive ornamental fish in the Philippines. The red-bellied pacu can spawn naturally in riverine condition however technique of artificial spawning using hormone is also practiced there. The production of red-bellied pacu is although confined in aquaculture ponds yet incidences of its occurrences in natural water bodies have been reported .
Pacu is although a plant eater, it is also molluscivorous. It has been found to control the abundance of the golden apple snail Pomacea canaliculata in simulated rice field in screen house condition. The molluscivorous feeding habit may be considered as a potential invasive character when the fish may impact on native mollusks such as the native snail Pila conica and freshwater clam Corbicula manilensis.
The red-bellied pacu, Piaractus brachypomus has also been reported to invade in Iran . Two specimens of 177 mm (Standard Length) long pacu were captured from Zarivar Lake in October 2015 and January 2016 . However, it could not be determined how this exotic fish species reached the lake nor the scientists could determine its actual abundance . Nevertheless, the aquarium trade, which is though, a very small business is blamed for its inadvertant releases in the lake. The incidental releases by aquarium hobbyists and aquarium trade has been responsible for the introduction of P. brachypomus into the natural waters. Most exotic fish species introduced into the Zarivar Lake has been found as a result of unmanaged aquaculture by the Iranian Departments of Fisheries and Environment and Marivan’s Fishing Cooperatives .
A piranha-like fish has been reported to be captured from a natural water body in north eastern Hungary in 2016. The captured specimen was examined based on the morphological appearance and the teething patterns of the fish. It was identified as a member of pacus (Serrasalmidae family). Since three pacu species, Piaractus brachypomus, P. mesopotamicus and Colossoma macropomum, are common species available in Hungary in the aquarium fish trade, characteristics of the studied invaded specimen were when compared with their relevant morphological data of the three species and also from the literature it was found to resemble most closely with Piaractus brachypomus. The captured specimen from natural aquatic body was confirmed as the pirapitinga Piaractus brachypomus (Cuvier, 1818) .
Occurrences of red-bellied pacu in India have been recorded from several natural aquatic bodies raising alarms and concerns of scientists. It is reported to occur in the Vellayani, the second largest freshwater lake in Thiruvananthapuram district of Kerala State in the southern part of Western Ghats region . Presence of pacu has also been reported from Pamba River in Kerala, which is known for its inland fishery resources and great biodiversity . Zeena and Beevi (2014)  reported captures of pacu from Muvattupuzha River, Kerala. The occurrence of Piaractus brachypomus has also been interestingly reported from the Vembanad Lake. The Vembanad Lake is the largest coastal lagoon on the southwest coast of India with a catchment area of 14500 km2 drained by seven rivers which are the Chalakudy, Periyar, Muvattupuzha, Meenachil, Manimala, Pamba and Achankovil, along with a large number of canals originating and flowing through Western Ghats. The region is known as one of the 34 global biodiversity hotspots of the world . Presence of red-bellied pacu Piaractus brachypomus has also been reported from Krishna and Godavari rivers of Telangana [33,34].
Some of the recent reports on the incidents of inadvertant releases of pacu that gravitated into natural water bodies especially in the biodiversity rich areas in India are definitely considered as serious concern and are alarming in response to the heedless interventions of the aquaculturists and emanating environmental changes. The pacu introduction in India has not been scientifically evaluated and hence its invasiveness still remains a query. A plastic diet, large body size and longevity (up to 70 cm SL and 28 years  and the capacity to achieve large local abundances and wide distributions, are some of the characteristics that support the invasive characters of the species . Whatsoever may be the scenario, established selfsustaining populations P. brachypomus have not been recorded so far due to the low frequency of individuals occurring in natural bodies. Nevertheless, there is a great possibility that a gradual release of these long-living fishes provides favourable conditions for growth, spawning, and establishment. The issues and concerns of possibilities of adversities on the biodiversity and ecosystem services attract serious attention of the policy makers and the scientific community to address them looking into larger interest of the farmers community, society and the environment.
- Chatterjee NR, Mazumdar B. Induced breeding of pacu (Piaractus brachypomus) in captivity with pituitary extract. Aquaculture Asia. 2009;14: 23.
- Singh AK, Lakra WS. Risk and benefit assessment of alien fish species of the aquaculture and aquarium trade into India. Reviews in Aquaculture. 2011;3;3-18.
- Froese, Rainer, Pauly, et al. "Piaractus brachypomus" in FishBase. 2017.
- Singh AK, Dinesh Kumar, Abubakar Ansari.Commercial farming of the Red belly Pacu. Aquaculture Asia-Pacific. 2012;8:48-9.
- Jegu M. Serrasalminae (Pacus and piranhas). In: Checklist of the freshwater fishes of South and Central America. 2003:182-96.
- Hashimoto DT, Senhorini JA, Foresti F, et al. Interspecific fish hybrids in Brazil: management of genetic resources for sustainable use. Rev Aquaculture. 2012;4:108-18.
- Hashimoto DT, Senhorini JA, Foresti F, et al. Genetic Identification of F1 and Post-F1 Serrasalmid Juvenile Hybrids in Brazilian Aquaculture. PLOS ONE. 2014;9.
- Moraes G, Avilez IM, Hori TSF. Comparison between Biochemical responses of the teleost Pacu and its hybrid Tambacu (Piaractus mesopotamicus x Colossoma macropomum)to short term nitrite exposure. Braz J Biol. 2006;66:1103-08.
- Datta MK, Nandeesha MC. Pacu (Piaractus brachypomus), an acid water loving exotic finfish, enters Indian aquaculture scene. Fishing Chimes. 2006;26:10-2.
- Ghosh Subrath, Datta MK. Farming of Red bellied Pacu (Piaractus brachypomus) in India. Fishing Chimes. 2014;34:32-39.
- Goulding M, Carvalho ML. Life history and management of the tambaqui (Colossoma macropomum , Characidae): an imponant Amazon food fish. Revista Brasileira de Zoologia. 1982;1:107-33.
- Saint-Paul U. Potential for aquaculture of South American fresh water ítshes: review. Aquaculture. 1986;54:205-40.
- Van dcr Meer MB. Fccds and feeding strategies for Colossoma mucmpomum (Cuvier 1 818). Fish growth as related lo dietary protein. Doctoral dissertation. Wageningen Agricultura University. Printed by Ponsen & Louijen, Wagcningen, Netherlands. 1997.
- Kumar Aditya PK, Pradhana PC, Das SM, et al. Growth performance and compatibility of pacu, Piaractus brachypomus with Indian major carps in polyculture system. Aquaculture. 2018;490:236-9.
- Anon. Annual Report of ICAR-National Bureau of Fish Genetic Resources, Lucknow 2016-17, 2017;132.
- Belton Ben, Arun Padiyar, Ravibabu G. Boom and bust in Andhra Pradesh: Development and transformation inIndia's domestic aquaculture value chain. Aquaculture. 2017;470:196-206.
- Anon. ICAR-CIFA. Annual Report 2016-17. ICARCentral Institute of Freshwater Aquaculture, Bhubaneswar, India. 2017;176.
- Bechara JA, Roux JP, Dıaz JFR, et al. The effect of dietary protein level on pond water quality and feed utilization efficiency of Pacu Piaractus mesopotamicus (Holmberg, 1887). Aquaculture Research. 2005;36:546-53.
- Barbieri Edison, Ana Cristina Vigliar Bondioli. Acute toxicity of ammonia in Pacu fish (Piaractus mesopotamicus, Holmberg, 1887) at different temperatures levels. Aquaculture Research. 2015;46:565-71.
- Abimorad EG, Favero GC, Castellani D, et al. Dietary supplementation of lysine and/or methionine on performance, nitrogen retention and excretion in Pacu Piaractus mesopotamicus reared in cages. Aquaculture. 2009;295:266-70.
- Barbieri Edison, Ana Cristina Vigliar Bondioli. Acute toxicity of ammonia in Pacu fish (Piaractus mesopotamicus, Holmberg, 1887) at different temperatures levels. Aquaculture Research. 2015;46:565-71.
- Konrad DA, Jacquers I, Joseph SO, et al. Effect of Oxygen Saturation in Water on Reproductive Performances of Pacu Piaractus brachypomus. Journal of the World Aquaculture Society. 2003;34:441-9.
- Ros angela K, Jomori Ronald Luz K, et al. Effect of Salinity on Larval Rearing of Pacu, Piaractus mesopotamicus, a freshwater species. Journal of The World Aquaculture Society. 2012;43:423-32.
- Howard, Brian Clark, Brian Clark Howard. “13 Scariest Freshwater Fish: Piranha”, National Geographic. 2012.
- Rick Spilman. “Beware the Red-Bellied Pacu? TesticleBiting Fish Invading Denmark?” (On-line). 2013.
- Arsenia G. Cagauan. Red-bellied Pacu in the Philippines. Journal of Environmental Science and Management. 2007;10:42-7.
- Zarei F, Rajabi-Maham H. First record of exotic Piaractus brachypomus Cuvier, 1818 (Characiformes: Serrasalmidae) from the Zarivar Lake, Western Iran. Journal of Applied Ichthyology. 2017;33:1-3.
- Harka A, Szepesi Sz, Nyeste K. First record of pirapitinga Piaractus brachypomus Cuvier, 1818 in a natural waterbody of Hungary. Pisces Hungarici. 2017;11:35-9.
- Reenamole GR, George D’cruz (2015). New Record of Exotic Fish Red Bellied Pacu, Piaractus brachypomus (Cuvier, 1818) From Vellayani Fresh Waterlake, Southwest Coast Of India. International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR). 2013;4:2319-7064, 1106-10.
- Rani S. Dharan, E. Sherly Williams. First record of the pirapitinga Piaractus brachypomus, Cuvier, 1818 (actinopterygii: serrasalmidae) in Pamba river Kerala, India. The Bioscan. 2017;2:121-4.
- Zeena KV, Beevi KSJ. On a report of red-bellied pacu Piaractus brachypomus (Cuvier, 1818)(Characiformes: Characidae) from Muvattupuzha River, Kerala, India. Journal of Bombay Natural History Society. 2014;111:138-40.
- Srinivas K, Revichandran C, Maheswaran PA, et al. Propagation of tides in the Cochin estuarine system, southwest coast of India. Indian J Mar Sci. 2003;32:14-24.
- Johnson JA, Paromita R, Sivakumar K. Report of new invasive fish, red-bellied piranha (Pygocentrus nattereri) in Godavari River, Andhra Pradesh. The Newsletter of the South Asia Office of the IUCN SSC/WI Freshwater Fish Specialist Group. 2014;2:8-10.
- Laxmappa B. Exotic fish species in aquaculture and aquatic ecosystem in Telangana State, India. Journal of Aquatic Biology & Fisheries. 2016;4:1-7.
- Loubens G, Panfili J. Biologie de Piaractus brachypomus (Teleostei: Serrasalminae) dans le bassin du Mamoré (Amazonie bolivienne). Ichthyological Exploration of Freshwaters. 2001;12:51-64.