Correlation analysis between pulmonary function and chest radiograph in molybdenum mine works
- *Corresponding Author:
- Qiuhong Zhu
National Institute of Occupational Health and Poison Control
China Center for Disease Control and Prevention, China
Accepted on January 31, 2017
Objective: To study the impairment degree of pulmonary function in molybdenum silicosis miners and analysed the relationship between pulmonary function parameters and chest X-ray film.
Method: Seventy-five molybdenum mine silicosis cases and thirty-five healthy cases were reviewed. They underwent pulmonary function and chest radiography and compared the pulmonary function parameters in different chest X-ray manifestation.
Results: (1) With the step-up of silicosis category, every pulmonary function parameter decreased gradually. Compared with control, radiographic silicosis in stage showed significant difference in all parameters (p<0.05). And these four parameters also have statistical difference between stages I, II and III. (2)As the increased of regions related to silicotic lesions, the parameters level were slightly decrement and more significant reductions with progressive massive fibrosis in FEV1,V75,V50 and V25 (p<0.05). (3) The differences in small opacities classes and the density of small opacities of silicosis were not lead to transparent discrepancy in all pulmonary function parameters.
Conclusion: The pulmonary ventilation function is mainly in relation to silicosis stage and the formation or the degree of massive fibrosis.
Clinical characteristics, Pulmonary function, Chest radiography, Molybdenum, Silicosis.
Silicosis is one of the pneumoconiosis which has the highest incidence rate at present. It is mostly occurrenced in coal or iron miners, building road workers, stone fragmentation and processing employers, quartz processing workers, and so on. Silicosis is not a benign disease; silica exposure is the primary cause, and the lung function loss in silicotics is directly attributable to the fibrotic lung disease . More recent data have shown chronic simple silicosis to be a significant lung disease [1,2]. Silicosis reflects a failure in adequate control of occupational dust exposure. The disorder is associated with radiologic pulmonary nodular opacity. Chronic silicosis generally occurs after prolonged low in density exposure to dust containing crystalline silica. There is a consistent association between increased pulmonary function abnormalities and silica dust exposure despite the concentration within the current allowable level of Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) . In this study, we recruited seventy-five subjects who are silicosis patients from the same molybdenum mine. Pulmonary function tests and chest X-ray were performed to evaluate pulmonary function test results of different stages and analyse the relationship between pulmonary function and chest radiograph.
Materials and Methods
This study was conducted in a molybdenum mine in a small town of China. This study selects seventy-five patients with silicosis patients in molybdenum mine. They are all chisel stone workers. The cases are all masculinity, aged 33 to 56 years, averaged 42.5 years. The length of occupational service was 3.5 to 23 years, averaged 10.25 years. Thirty-five healthy men who was nondust as matched control, aged 32 to 54 years, averaged 42.54 years. They were observed by routine lung function test and chest radiography. The results were compared with the measured value of 35 healthy cases. Based on the (Diagnosis of occupational pneumoconiosis) (GBZ70-2015), we diagnosed 10 silicosis of category I, 44 silicosis of category II and 21 silicosis of category III (Silicosis was defined as small opacities profusion of ≥ 1/0 for at least two lung fields and category III was defined when the area of massive fibrosis to be equal to or bigger than square centimetre 2 × 1). We have eliminated the interference of ir-investigation agents.
First, a single posterior-anterior 120~125 KV was obtained. All chest radiographs were reviewed by three occupational physicians who were certified by Ministry of Health of the People’s Republic of China. After completion of the chest radiograph, the lung function tests were done according to the standards of the American Thoracic Society  by just one technician. The equipment used was the MIR Spirolab II. The test was performed by the single-breath method. The patients were standing when they were testing. We checked three times continuously and select the best for recording. The parameters we used was Forced Vital Capacity (FVC), forced expiratory volume in one second (FEV1), FEV1 to FVC ratio (FEV1%), Peak Expiratory Flow (PEF), 75% vital capacity (V75), 50% vital capacity (V50) and 25% vital capacity (V25). We used Ttest on the values of all pulmonary function parameters.
We collected one hundred and ten lung function results (seventy-five of silicosis and thirty-five of control people) and seventy-five chest radiographs. We compared pulmonary function parameters in different stages of pneumoconiosis and normal subjects, and analysed the variation tendency of pulmonary function parameters in different distribution regions of small opacities, density of small opacities and opacities classes. In order to understand the difference of lung function between pneumoconiosis and normal population, the pulmonary function parameters of the two groups were compared. Table 1 shows that they are mostly identical in FVC between category and control, except for that, there are significantly lower than the controller in all pulmonary function parameters values of categories I-III (p<0.05). Furthermore, there is differ-degree discrepancy in all pulmonary function parameters values compared category I and II with category III, especially in FEV1, V75, V50 and V25. But there are no significantly difference between category I and II.
|The average value of pulmonary function parameters|
|FVC (L/S)||FEV1 (L/S)||FEV1 (%)||PEF (L/S)||V75 (L/S)||V50 (L/S)||V25 (L/S)|
|I||10||3.71 ± 0.48*||3.08 ± 0.49*▼||78.60 ±7.02▼||6.55 ± 1.15▼||5.32 ± 2.22*▼||3.51±1.14*▼||1.23±0.45*▼|
|Ii||44||3.85 ± 0.65▼||2.83± 0.66*▼||79.65 ± 7.87*||6.11 ± 2.23*▼||5.26 ± 1.89*▼||3.22±1.32*▼||1.14±0.86*▼|
|Iii||21||3.13 ± 0.58▼||2.22±0.56▼||70.16 ± 12.4▼||5.03 ± 2.21▼||3.87 ± 2.21▼||2.32±1.25▼||0.78±0.34▼|
*Compared category I and II with category III, p<0.05. ▼Compared category I, II and III with control, p<0.05.
Table 1. The average value of pulmonary function parameters of silicosis cases.
In general, with the increase in the distribution of pulmonary fibrosis, lung function should also be reduced, so we observed the relationship between the distribution regions of small opacities and pulmonary function parameters. In all seventyfive silicosis, the small opacities are relating to four lung regions at least and mostly relate to six lung regions. From Table 2, we can see that all pulmonary function parameters decreased gradually with the increased of distribution regions of small opacities and have statistical difference between massive fibrosis and 4, 5 and 6 distribution regions of small opacities, particularly in four parameters, such as FEV1, V75, V50 and V25 (p<0.05). But there are no significantly difference between 4 and 5, 6 distribution regions.
|n||The average value of pulmonary function parameters|
|FVC (L/S)||FEV1 (L/S)||FEV1 (%)||PEF (L/S)||V75 (L/S)||V50 (L/S)||V25 (L/S)|
|4||11||4.04 ± 0.35▼||3.02 ± 0.76▼||77.58 ± 7.11||6.22 ± 1.55||5.33 ± 2.12*||3.44 ± 1.43*||1.35 ± 0.33*|
|5||10||4.14 ± 0.56||3.05 ± 0.84*||85.69 ± 4.65*||6.98 ± 2.02||5.76 ± 2.15*||3.76 ± 1.21▼||1.67 ± 0.45▼|
|6||33||4.15 ± 0.48||2.89 ± 0.73▼||80.24 ± 8.43▼||6.54 ± 2.03*||4.88 ± 1.87*||2.88 ± 1.27▼||1.21 ± 0.64*|
|Massive fibrosis||21||3.47 ± 0.59||2.38 ± 0.69||69.98 ± 12.8||4.97 ± 2.32||3.67 ± 2.21||2.12 ± 1.31||0.0.89 ± 0.44|
*Compared region 4, 5 and 6 with massive fibrosis, p<0.05.*Compared region 4, 5 and 6 with massive fibrosis, p<0.05.
Table 2. The relationship between the distribution regions of small opacities and the values of pulmonary function parameters in silicosis.
In general, the higher the density of small opacities, the more diffuses the lesion. Therefore, we studied the changes of pulmonary function in different density of small opacities. With the increased of the density of small opacities of silicosis,almost every pulmonary function parameter take on a tendency of descent. But after statistical analysis, there is no significantly difference in all parameters based on different density. Only of FVC, it has statistical difference compared density 1 with density 3 (p<0.05). As for the average value of FEV1%, PEF, V75 and V25 of density 2 are higher than those of density 1 probably resulted by the reason that there are few cases in density 1 and it has little effect on the change tendency of the population (Table 3).
|Density||n||The average value of pulmonary function parameters|
|FVC (L/S)||FEV1 (L/S)||FEV1 (%)||PEF (L/S)||V75 (L/S)||V50 (L/S)||V25 (L/S)|
|1||8||3.76 ± 0.54*||3.05 ± 0.43||79.54 ± 6.78||6.20 ± 1.55||5.44 ± 2.21||3.54 ± 1.12||1.41 ± 0.38|
|2||17||3.54 ± 0.76||3.01 ± 0.62||81.78 ± 7.54||6.51 ± 2.67||5.58 ± 2.14||3.56 ± 1.24||1.47 ± 0.55|
|3||29||3.33 ± 0.75||2.71 ± 0.40||86.12 ± 7.17||6.21 ± 1.43||4.98 ± 1.89||2.88 ± 0.86||1.23 ± 0.43|
*Compared density 1 with density 3, p<0.05.
Table 3. The relationship between the density of small opacities and the values of pulmonary function parameters in silicosis.
Arguably, different small opacities classes on lung function effects should not be the same. We speculate that with the increase of small opacities diameter, lung function damage should also be increased. From the follow Table 4, the values are decreased gradually with the increased of the diameter of small opacities in every pulmonary function parameter, but have no statistical difference (p>0.05).
|Classes||n||The average value of pulmonary function parameters|
|FVC (L/S)||FVC (L/S)||FVC (L/S)||FVC (L/S)||FVC (L/S)||FVC (L/S)||FVC (L/S)|
|q||21||4.14 ± 0.33||3.01 ± 0.33||82.23 ± 6.07||6.21 ± 1.33||5.03 ± 1.32||3.41 ± 0.88||1.29 ± 0.44|
|r||36||4.36 ± 0.56||3.11 ± 0.54||80.31 ± 7.56||6.55 ± 2.21||5.46 ± 2.23||3.13 ± 1.12||1.32 ± 0.54|
Table 4. The relationship between the small opacities classes and the values of pulmonary function parameters in silicosis.
Molybdenum is a kind of rare metal. The sixty five patients select for this paper come from one of China’s largest molybdenum mines, where the mining and processing of molybdenum have become the most important growth driver for the local economy, majority of the local residents are thereby involved in the rock-digging work inside the well. The content of silicon in the rock layer of the concerned region ranges from 40% to 50%; meanwhile, the bad production environment along with the poor protection measures all contribute to the high incidence, fast development as well as severity of silicosis, as is rarely seen nationwide. Silicosis always attacks workers after their 5 to 10 years of rock-digging work. The chest radiograph indicates that the lungs are permeated by small opacities classes, the shape is mainly classes r, followed by classes q, without classes p; density is mainly grade 3, grade 2 and grade 1 account for a very small proportion; six lung regions are usually attacked, some patients have massive fibrosis of silicosis, in a distinctive form of “snow flake”.
The examination of pulmonary function is designed to objectively reflect the functions of lungs without any hurt, to discover any damage to respiratory system at early stage and to conduct clinical analysis, observation of curative effect, appraisal of work ability as well as professional epidemiology study. Pulmonary dysfunction was found to be associated with silicosis and to increase in proportion with the degree of silicotic nodule profusion. The average value of the lungs function obtained from this group of patients is obviously lower than those of the controlled group. Because there is an association between silica exposure levels above the allowable OSHA exposure limits and pulmonary function loss in individuals without silicosis [1,5-8]. So we can believe that the dust concentration in this mine is very high although there haven’t actually measurement in the working environment. In some completed studies [9-11]. FVC and FEV1 often has been investigated and decreased noticeable. Ooi et al. even confirmed that progressive massive fibrosis was significant determinants of FEV1 . And silicosis found at autopsy was associated with lung function impairment . In this study, other parameters besides FVC and FEV1 have been also decreased of silicosis, especially in FEV1, V75, V50 and V25. Therefore, various parameters shall be taken into consideration when applying FVC% and FEV1% to determine whether or not the patients have been attacked by respiratory difficulties. But determination of the specific limit value; however, shall be supported by much more epidemiology study information and based on the patients’ condition.
Another notable point is that the average value of FEV1% in category II is larger than category I, distribution of small opacities in five regions is larger than that in four lung regions and grade 2 density is bigger than grade 1 density. Reasons behind this fact maybe that VC of the former drops more evidently, but flexibility and retraction of lungs are not reduced, so majority of VC is breathed out within one second, thus leading to abnormal rise in FEV1%. Someone else suggest that it may be due to building of muscles in this job . The facts agree with the pathological and physiological features of silicosis.
Just early, someone have a suggestion that impaired lung function with silicosis is due to progressive massive fibrosis . As indicated in this study, once the massive fibrosis attacks the silicosis patients, various parameters of lung function shall decrease evidently Even compared with the six lung regions affected patients, their parameters are still sharply different in terms of statistics, particularly in FEV1, V75, V50 and V25. The four indicators reflect the obstruction condition of upper and lower respiratory, respectively. Through the investigation, the whole respiratory system, thereby, of silicosis patients at later stage is believed to be damaged to various extents.
As we all know, with the increase of silicosis stage, the incidence percentage of pulmonary function damage and mixed respiratory difficulties increased evidently as well. Combined with this study, the difference in terms of small opacities classes, density and number of regions affected are not result in evident difference in abnormality of lung function. So we think that respiratory function evaluation of silicosis patients shall be comprehensively assessment based on the silicosis stage, type of lung damage as well as damage degree. The small opacities classes, density and distribution scope is the marker by which the silicosis stage determined they cannot serve as the single indicators for evaluation of the respiratory function.
As reported by recent documents, there are new opinions. Tiwari demonstrated that HRCT were better in diagnosing dust-related interstitial lung fibrosis compared to chest radiographs. Computed Tomography (CT), especially High- Resolution CT (HRCT), plays a very important role in determining the diagnosis of respiratory diseases such as pneumoconiosis . The experts developed the International Classification of HRCT for Occupational and Environmental Respiratory Diseases (ICOERD) . And Berk et al.  suggested that HRCT can be considered a useful support to conventional chest radiography. So we propose if we can formulate series diagnosis standard films of computed tomography to use in the future.
In this study, we analysed the characteristic changes of chest X-ray changes and pulmonary function in patients with molybdenum silicosis and trying to find the relationship between the change of chest X-ray and lung function parameters. To sum up, it is difficult to accurately determine the pulmonary function of pneumoconiosis patients only with the change of chest radiograph, but the comprehensive analysis of the parameters can be used to understand the changes of lung function in patients with pneumoconiosis. For chest X-ray changes, can only say that the development of massive fibrosis can be inferred that there may be adverse effects on lung function and more evidences are needed to confirm the conclusion.
- Ehrlich RI, Myers JE, Water NJM, Thompson ML, Churchyard GJ. Lung function loss in relation to silica dust exposure in South African gold miners.Occup Environ Med 2011; 68: 96-101.
- Rushton L. Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and occupational exposure to silica.Rev Environ Health 2007; 22: 255-272.
- Hertzberg VS, Rosenman KD, Reilly MJ, Rice CH. Effect of occupational silica exposure on pulmonary function.Chest 2002; 122: 721-728.
- American Thoracic Society. Standardization of spirometry, 1994 update. Am J RespirCrit Care Med 1995; 152: 1107-1136.
- Malmberg P, Hedenstrom H, Sundblad BM. Changes in lung function of granite crushers exposed to moderately high silica concentrations: a 12 year follow up.Br J Ind Med 1993; 50: 726-731.
- Mamuya SH, Bratveit M, Mashalla YJ, Moen BE. Airflow limitation among workers in a labour-intensive coal mine in Tanzania.Int Arch Occup Environ Health 2007; 80: 567-575.
- Green DA, McAlpine G, Semple S, Cowie H, Seaton A. Mineral dust exposure in young Indian adults: an effect on lung growth?Occup Environ Med 2008; 65: 306-310.
- Bruske I, Thiering E, Heinrich J, Huster KM, Nowak D. Respirable quartz dust exposure and airway obstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis.Occup Environ Med 2014; 71: 583-589.
- Mohner M, Kersten N,Gellissen J.Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and longitudinal changes in pulmonary function due to occupational exposure to respirable quartz. Occup Environ Med 2013;70:9-14.
- Suhr H, Bang B, Moen BE. Respiratory health among quartz-exposed slate workers--a problem even today.Occup Med (Lond) 2003; 53: 406-407.
- Forastiere F, Goldsmith DF, Sperati A, Rapiti E, Miceli M. Silicosis and lung function decrements among female ceramic workers in Italy.Am J Epidemiol 2002; 156: 851-856.
- Ooi GC,Tsang KW, Cheung TF.Silicosis in 76 men: qualitative and quantitative CT evaluation-clinical-radiologic correlation study. Radiology 2003; 228: 816-825.
- Hnizdo E,Murray J,Davison A.Correlation between autopsy findings for chronic obstructive airways disease and in-life disability in South African gold miners. Int Arch Occup Environ Health 2000;73:235-244.
- Mathur ML, Dixit AK. A study of forced vital capacity and its predictors among the sand stone quarry workers.Indian J PhysiolPharmacol 1999; 43: 347-354.
- Wade WA,Petsonk EL, Young B.Severe occupational pneumoconiosis among West Virginian coal miners: one hundred thirty-eight cases of progressive massive fibrosis compensated between 2000 and 2009.Chest 2011;139:1458-1462.
- Tiwari RR.Agreement between chest radiography and high-resolution computed tomography in diagnosing dust-related interstitial lung fibrosis.ToxicolInd Health 2015;31:235-238.
- Tamura T,Suganuma N,Hering KG.Relationships (I) of international classification of high-resolution computed tomography for occupational and environmental respiratory diseases with the ILO international classification of radiographs of pneumoconioses for parenchymal abnormalities.Ind Health 2015;53:260-270.
- Berk S,Dogan DO,Gumus C.Relationship between radiological (X-ray/HRCT), spirometric and clinical findings in dental technicians pneumoconiosis.ClinRespir J 2016;10:67-73.